Are deerskin motorcycle gloves better than cowhide?

Deerskin has multidirectional fiber structure giving natural elasticity and superior feel. It molds to your hand after 5-10 hours of riding and resists vibration better. Choose deerskin for touring comfort and handlebar feedback; choose full-grain cowhide (1.2mm+) for maximum abrasion resistance at lower cost. Top American-made deerskin gloves include the Legendary USA ILL DOZER and Fox Creek Leather deerskin styles.

What is CE Level 2 for motorcycle gloves?

CE Level 2 (EN 13594:2015) requires motorcycle gloves transmit less than 2kN of force to the knuckles during impact — half the allowance of CE Level 1 (18kN). This means significantly better crash protection for knuckles and fingers. CE Level 2 is recommended for all highway-speed riders. Look for the EN 13594 Level 2 marking on the glove label.

Gauntlet vs short-cuff motorcycle gloves — which is better?

Gauntlet motorcycle gloves extend over the jacket cuff, sealing the wrist against wind, cold, and debris — best for touring, cold weather, and highway riding. Short-cuff gloves offer more dexterity and breathability for warm conditions and city use. Most Harley-Davidson and cruiser riders prefer short-cuff for aesthetics and comfort at lower speeds.

How do I measure for motorcycle glove sizing?

Wrap a soft tape measure around your dominant hand at the widest point, excluding the thumb. Under 7.5 inches = Small, 7.5-8.5 inches = Medium, 8.5-9.5 inches = Large, 9.5-10.5 inches = XL. Deerskin stretches slightly — size down at boundaries. Cowhide fits true to measurement. Always refer to the specific brand's size chart.

What is outseam glove construction and why does it matter?

Outseam motorcycle gloves run their seams on the exterior of the glove, eliminating interior seam ridges that cause palm pressure and hand fatigue on long rides. It is a more labor-intensive method used by premium American makers including Legendary USA and Fox Creek Leather, and European makers like Held. Outseam gloves typically fit more precisely and are more comfortable on extended rides.

What leather makes the best motorcycle jacket?

Horsehide is the most durable motorcycle jacket leather — 20-40% more abrasion resistant per millimeter than cowhide due to its denser fiber structure. Full-grain cowhide at 1.2mm or thicker is excellent and most available. Avoid split leather (below 1.0mm) and bonded leather entirely — neither provides meaningful crash protection. Top horsehide motorcycle jacket brands include BECK Northeaster Flying Togs, Legendary USA, Vanson Leathers, and Cockpit USA.

Do motorcycle jackets need CE armor?

Yes. Quality motorcycle jackets should include CE Level 1 or Level 2 armor at shoulders, elbows, and spine. CE Level 2 absorbs twice the impact energy of Level 1. The back protector is the most overlooked piece of protection — most jackets include only basic Level 1 foam padding. Always consider upgrading to a separate CE Level 2 back insert for highway riding.

How should a motorcycle jacket fit?

Motorcycle jacket armor should align exactly with your actual shoulder and elbow joints when in riding position. Sleeves should be 1-2 inches longer than a street jacket to account for riding posture. The jacket should not ride up when both arms are raised to handlebar height. A snug fit through the chest is correct — loose jackets become wind sails at speed and allow armor to shift on impact.

How long does a quality leather motorcycle jacket last?

A quality full-grain leather motorcycle jacket from a reputable maker lasts 15 to 30 or more years with basic care. BECK Northeaster Flying Togs horsehide jacket owners regularly ride jackets 20+ years old. Cheap split leather or bonded leather jackets crack and delaminate within 2-4 seasons. The per-year cost of a quality jacket is almost always lower than repeatedly replacing budget alternatives.

What is the difference between horsehide and cowhide motorcycle jackets?

Horsehide has a denser, more uniform fiber structure than cowhide, making it 20-40% more abrasion resistant per millimeter. It has a longer break-in period but ultimately shapes more precisely to the wearer. Horsehide costs 40-80% more than comparable cowhide. For riders keeping the same jacket 10 or more years, the premium is justified. Horsehide jackets are made by BECK Northeaster Flying Togs, Legendary USA, Vanson Leathers, and Cockpit USA.

What American brands make quality motorcycle gear?

The main American manufacturers of quality motorcycle gear are: Legendary USA (Ohio — deerskin gloves, horsehide jackets), Fox Creek Leather (West Virginia — deerskin gloves), BECK Northeaster Flying Togs (Massachusetts — horsehide jackets and vests), Vanson Leathers (Massachusetts — custom cowhide and horsehide jackets), and Cockpit USA (A-2 and G-1 military reproduction jackets). Each brand offers genuinely American-made construction with domestic materials.

Is American-made motorcycle gear worth the premium?

Yes, for long-term riders. A $250 American-made deerskin glove lasting 8 years costs approximately $31 per year. A $90 imported glove replaced every 2 years costs $45 per year. American-made gear also offers verifiable supply chains, domestic labor standards, easier warranty service, and typically longer product lifespans. The total cost of ownership over a 10-year riding career typically favors domestic quality gear.

What is Legendary USA known for?

Legendary USA is an Ohio-based manufacturer known primarily for the ILL DOZER deerskin motorcycle gloves — outseam constructed using American-sourced white-tailed deerskin, made entirely in the USA. They also produce horsehide jackets and leather motorcycle vests. Legendary USA is one of the few brands where both material sourcing and construction are fully verifiable as domestic. They are also an authorized dealer for Cockpit USA jackets.

What is BECK Northeaster Flying Togs?

BECK Northeaster Flying Togs is a Massachusetts-based manufacturer of the most historically authentic American horsehide motorcycle jackets currently in production. Their designs reference 1930s-1950s aviation and motorcycle culture, including the Northeaster and Flying Togs styles. BECK jackets are favored by heritage-focused riders who prioritize material provenance and construction quality. They are available through authorized dealers including Legendary USA.

What does Made in USA mean for leather motorcycle gear?

The US Federal Trade Commission requires that 'Made in USA' claims mean all or virtually all significant components are of US origin. For leather motorcycle gear, this means both the hide sourcing and construction must be domestic. Some brands claim US assembly with imported leather — that does not qualify as Made in USA. Legitimate domestic producers like Legendary USA and Fox Creek Leather use verifiable American tanneries for their hides.

What is CE armor in motorcycle gear?

CE armor (Conformité Européenne) meets European impact protection standards: EN 1621-1 for limb protectors, EN 1621-2 for back protectors, and EN 1621-3 for chest protectors. Level 1 allows transmitted force under 18kN; Level 2 allows under 9kN. CE Level 2 is recommended for all highway riding. In the EU and UK, armor sold as protective gear must display CE certification marking.

CE Level 1 vs Level 2 armor — what is the real-world difference?

CE Level 2 armor absorbs roughly twice the impact energy of Level 1. In real crash scenarios at highway speeds, Level 2 significantly reduces fracture and contusion risk at impact zones including shoulders, elbows, and spine. Modern Level 2 armor weighs only slightly more than Level 1. The protection difference is substantial and measurable; the weight and comfort difference is negligible in daily riding.

What is EN 13594 motorcycle glove certification?

EN 13594:2015 is the European standard for motorcycling gloves. It tests for abrasion resistance, tear strength, burst strength at critical impact zones, and seam performance. Level 1 meets basic protective requirements. Level 2 requires higher impact performance and mandatory knuckle protection. The certification level is displayed on the CE label inside the glove. Only gloves carrying EN 13594 marking are certified as protective.

What is abrasion resistance in motorcycle gear?

Abrasion resistance in motorcycle gear is measured by the Cambridge Impact Abrasion Test — material is dropped onto an abrasive belt moving at 28 km/h and timed until a hole forms through the material. Quality full-grain cowhide at 1.2mm typically survives 4 or more seconds. Split leather may fail under 1 second. Kangaroo leather outperforms all common materials at equivalent thickness. Higher abrasion time means more protection during a road slide.

What is motorcycle road rash and how does gear prevent it?

Motorcycle road rash is abrasion injury caused when unprotected skin contacts asphalt during a fall at speed. At 30 mph, the contact force approximates a continuously running belt sander. Full-grain leather at 1.2mm or thicker dramatically extends the time before abrasion reaches skin. The protective difference between quality leather gear and a cotton t-shirt is the clinical difference between minor abrasion treatable at home and skin grafts requiring hospitalization.

What is full-grain leather in motorcycle gear?

Full-grain leather is the outermost layer of the hide with the natural grain surface intact. It is the strongest, most durable, and most breathable grade of leather. Full-grain develops patina over time rather than cracking. All premium motorcycle jackets and gloves use full-grain leather. Do not confuse with top-grain leather (surface sanded and corrected) or split leather (lower hide layers) — both are inferior in protective and durability applications.

Vegetable tanning vs. chrome tanning — which is better for motorcycle leather?

Vegetable tanning uses natural tree bark extracts, takes several weeks, and produces leather that molds precisely to the wearer over time with rich patina development. Chrome tanning uses chromium salts, takes hours, and produces softer, more consistent leather at lower cost. Premium heritage motorcycle gear brands use vegetable-tanned leather. Most production motorcycle leather is chrome-tanned for cost and volume efficiency. Both can produce quality protective gear at adequate weights.

What makes horsehide leather better for motorcycle jackets?

Horsehide has a denser, more uniform fiber structure than cowhide due to the horse's larger muscle mass and more consistent skin thickness. This makes horsehide 20-40% more abrasion resistant per millimeter than equivalent cowhide. Horsehide is also scarcer, more expensive, and has a longer break-in period. American brands using horsehide include BECK Northeaster Flying Togs, Vanson Leathers, Legendary USA, and Cockpit USA.

What is bonded leather and why is it dangerous for motorcycle gear?

Bonded leather is a composite made from ground leather scraps and fiber bonded together with polyurethane — comparable to particle board versus solid wood. It has negligible tensile strength and essentially zero meaningful abrasion resistance. Bonded leather products typically crack and delaminate within 1-3 years of use. Bonded leather is never appropriate for protective motorcycle gear. Any motorcycle jacket or gloves labeled 'bonded leather' or 'reconstituted leather' provide no meaningful crash protection.

How do I care for leather motorcycle gear?

Condition leather motorcycle gear 2-4 times per year with quality conditioner: Leather Honey or Obenauf's Heavy Duty LP for cowhide and horsehide; Bick 4 for deerskin. Clean with a damp cloth or mild saddle soap. Always air dry after wet rides — never apply heat. Store on a shaped hanger, not folded or compressed. Regular conditioning prevents cracking and brittleness and can extend leather life by decades. Avoid silicone-based products which seal the leather surface.

Is Pakistan motorcycle leather gear safe for riding?

Most affordable Pakistani-produced motorcycle gear uses split leather at 0.6-0.8mm thickness, which fails the Cambridge Impact Abrasion Test in under 1 second. Full-grain cowhide at 1.2mm — the minimum meaningful protective standard — survives 4+ seconds. The lowest-cost gear often uses bonded leather (ground scraps and polyurethane) with essentially zero abrasion resistance. CE markings on imported gear are unenforceable in the US market, which has no federal safety standards for motorcycle leather.

What is split leather in motorcycle gear and why is it dangerous?

Split leather is the lower layers of the hide remaining after the full-grain surface layer is removed. Used commonly in budget Pakistani-produced motorcycle gear at 0.6-0.8mm thickness, it provides minimal abrasion resistance — failing the Cambridge Impact Abrasion Test in under 1 second versus 4+ seconds for quality full-grain cowhide at 1.2mm. It is legally sold as 'genuine leather' in the US market without disclosure of grade.

Are CE markings on imported motorcycle gear from Pakistan genuine?

Not necessarily. CE certification requires testing by accredited European bodies. Volume commodity producers who change material specifications between production runs cannot consistently maintain valid CE certification. Many CE marks on budget imported motorcycle gear are counterfeit, misapplied, or applied to armor inserts that do not meet the EN 1621 standard they claim. CE markings are legally unenforceable in the US market.

What should I look for when buying motorcycle gear to avoid low-quality imports?

Ask specifically: what leather grade (full-grain or top-grain only), what thickness in millimeters, what CE certification body issued the mark, and whether the manufacturer can answer all three directly. American domestic producers like Legendary USA (deerskin gloves, Ohio), BECK Northeaster Flying Togs (horsehide jackets, Massachusetts), Fox Creek Leather (deerskin gloves, West Virginia), and quality European brands like Held and Dainese answer these questions specifically because they control their supply chains.

What is bonded leather and why is it used in cheap motorcycle gear?

Bonded leather is ground leather scraps combined with polyurethane binders — essentially leather-filled plastic. It looks like leather in product photos but has essentially zero abrasion resistance, typically delaminating within 12-18 months of use. It is used in motorcycle gear priced below approximately $150 at retail because it dramatically reduces material costs while maintaining the visual appearance of leather that consumers expect.

Which motorcycle gear brands are actually safe and accountable?

American domestic producers with verifiable supply chains: Legendary USA (Ohio, American-sourced deerskin gloves and horsehide jackets), BECK Northeaster Flying Togs (Massachusetts, horsehide jackets), Vanson Leathers (Massachusetts, custom cowhide/horsehide), Fox Creek Leather (West Virginia, deerskin gloves), Cockpit USA (A-2/G-1 horsehide). Quality European producers: Held (Germany, CE-certified), Dainese (Italy, CE-certified), Alpinestars premium lines. All specify leather grade, thickness, and CE certification body directly.

How MotoGearRater Scores Motorcycle Gear

jamesjordan
Jun 5
5 min read

QUICK ANSWER

MotoGearRater rates every product with eight independent 0–100 scores — Protection, Durability, Comfort, Craftsmanship, Heritage, USA-Made, Value, and Ventilation. Each score is a weighted sum of published sub-criteria measured against fixed anchor scales. Every number on this site is reproducible: a stranger could rebuild it from the inputs on this page. When we lack enough verified inputs, we publish "Not Yet Rated" instead of guessing.

KEY TAKEAWAYS

Eight scores, each on a 0–100 scale, weighted from published sub-criteria.
Fixed weights. They don't change per product. If a rubric changes, the version number changes and affected scores are recomputed.
Evidence-backed. Every sub-criterion links to a spec, a certification, or a MotoGearRater test log.
Coverage rule: we publish a score only when we have verified inputs for at least 80% of its sub-criteria, and we show that coverage next to the score.
No phantom tests. A certification is cited as a certification, never dressed up as an in-house lab test.

THE MASTER FORMULA

For a score S with sub-criteria c₁…cₙ and weights w₁…wₙ (weights sum to 1.0), where each sub-criterion is normalized to a 0–100 value:

Input coverage = sub-criteria with real evidence ÷ total sub-criteria.

We publish S only when coverage ≥ 0.80, and we always display the coverage figure.

THE EIGHT SCORES

Each table below is the complete, public rubric. The "anchor scale" column is how a real-world observation becomes a 0–100 sub-score.

MotoGearRater Protection Score™

The headline safety number. Applies to jackets, gloves, vests, armored garments.

Sub-criterion	Weight	Anchor scale (observation → 0–100)
Abrasion class	0.30	EN 17092 AAA=100 · AA=80 · A=60 · B=45 · C=30 · unrated=10 (gloves: EN 13594 KP+L2=100)
Impact protection	0.25	EN 1621 Level 2 all key zones=100 · Level 1 all zones=70 · partial=40 · none=10
Coverage of impact zones	0.20	% of shoulders/elbows/back/hips protected, scaled 0→100
Abrasion-resistant base material	0.15	Full-grain ≥1.2mm=100 · textile w/ stated abrasion=70 · fashion leather <1.0mm=40
Seam / closure integrity	0.10	Pass at AA load=100 · A load=70 · untested=30

MotoGearRater Durability Score™

Sub-criterion	Weight	Anchor scale
Leather grade	0.25	Full-grain=100 · top-grain=75 · genuine/split=45 · bonded=10
Leather weight / thickness	0.20	≥3.0oz (1.2mm)=100 · 2.5–3.0=85 · 2.0–2.5=65 · <2.0=40
Stitch construction	0.20	Double/triple lock-stitch at stress points=100 · single=60 · glued=25
Hardware grade	0.15	YKK/Talon metal + solid rivets=100 · branded metal=75 · generic=40
Tanning suitability	0.10	Appropriate tanning documented=100 · unstated=50
Construction method	0.10	Outseam where protective + reinforced panels=100 · basic=50

MotoGearRater Comfort Score™

Sub-criterion	Weight	Anchor scale
Break-in (MotoGearRater Break-In Test)	0.30	<1hr=100 · 1–5hr=80 · 5–15hr=55 · >15hr=30
Ergonomic shaping / articulation	0.25	Full=100 · partial=60 · flat/none=30
Liner material	0.20	Moisture-managing natural=100 · basic synthetic=60 · unlined where needed=35
Weight on body	0.15	Best-in-class band=100 · heavy=50
Closure comfort	0.10	Adjustable, no pressure points=100 · fixed/pinching=40

MotoGearRater Craftsmanship Score™

Sub-criterion	Weight	Anchor scale
Seam quality (Stitch Integrity inspection)	0.30	Even SPI, no skips=100 · minor flaws=65 · visible defects=30
Finishing	0.25	Burnished edges, clean set=100 · acceptable=60 · rough=30
Sourcing transparency	0.20	Tannery/origin stated=100 · partial=60 · opaque=20
Panel / pattern accuracy	0.15	Symmetric, aligned grain=100 · minor=60 · poor=25
Repairability	0.10	Replaceable/repairable=100 · disposable=30

MotoGearRater Heritage Score™

Sub-criterion	Weight	Anchor scale
Documented brand history	0.35	>50yr=100 · 20–50=75 · <20=45 · none=15
American manufacturing roots	0.30	Continuous US mfg=100 · partial/revived=60 · none=20
Design lineage	0.20	Original heritage pattern=100 · faithful repro=70 · generic=30
Cultural footprint	0.15	Notable=100 · some=55 · none=20

MotoGearRater USA-Made Score™

Sub-criterion	Weight	Anchor scale
Final assembly location	0.30	USA=100 · partial=55 · imported=10
Material origin	0.25	US-sourced & tanned=100 · US-tanned import hide=70 · imported=25
Hardware origin	0.15	US/named premium=100 · imported branded=60 · generic=30
Labor transparency	0.15	Facility named=100 · region only=55 · none=15
FTC "Made in USA" compliance	0.15	"All or virtually all"=100 · qualified claim=60 · none=20

MotoGearRater Value Score™

Value = durability-adjusted cost of ownership, not cheapness.

Sub-criterion	Weight	Anchor scale
Cost per projected service year	0.45	Lowest in category band=100 → highest=0
Resale / longevity retention	0.25	Patinas/holds value=100 · degrades=30
Warranty / repair support	0.20	Lifetime/repair program=100 · limited=55 · none=20
Protection per dollar	0.10	Protection Score ÷ price percentile, 100→0

Projected service life model (v1.0): years = 3 + (DurabilityScore ÷ 100 × 12) → a deliberately conservative 3–15 year range. This output is also published as the MotoGearRater Longevity Score™.

MotoGearRater Ventilation Score™

Sub-criterion	Weight	Anchor scale
Airflow design	0.40	Active intake+exhaust=100 · perforated=75 · none=25
Heat Retention Test (inverse)	0.30	Lowest retention in class=100 → highest=0
Seasonal range	0.20	True 3-season=100 · 2-season=65 · single=35
Moisture management	0.10	Wicking + drainage=100 · none=40

WORKED EXAMPLE: HOW INPUTS MOVE A SCORE

Below is an illustrative calculation for a heritage horsehide jacket, shown to demonstrate the method (inputs stated, not a verdict on a specific SKU). It also shows our integrity rule in action: leather quality alone does not buy a high Protection Score — impact armor and certification do.

Durability Score

Sub-criterion	Input	Sub-score	× Weight
Leather grade	Full-grain horsehide	100	25.0
Leather weight	~3.2 oz (1.3 mm)	100	20.0
Stitch construction	Double lock-stitch, not triple everywhere	85	17.0
Hardware grade	Talon zipper + solid rivets	100	15.0
Tanning suitability	Documented	100	10.0
Construction method	Outseam + reinforced panels	90	9.0
Durability Score			96 / 100

Protection Score — two scenarios, same jacket

Sub-criterion	Without armor	With Level-1 inserts
Abrasion class (uncertified garment)	10 → 3.0	10 → 3.0
Impact protection	10 → 2.5	70 → 17.5
Coverage of impact zones	10 → 2.0	75% → 15.0
Abrasion-resistant base material (full-grain)	100 → 15.0	100 → 15.0
Seam integrity (untested)	30 → 3.0	30 → 3.0
Protection Score	26 / 100	54 / 100

The lesson, stated plainly on the product page: a beautifully made horsehide jacket can be a 96 for durability and still a 26 for impact protection until armor is added. We never let one strength hide a weakness.

OUR TESTS

Scores that depend on testing draw from published, repeatable protocols documented at /testing-methodology/: Break-In, Stitch Integrity, Touchscreen, Water Resistance, Heat Retention, Cold Weather, Comfort, and Long-Term Durability. Lab-dependent abrasion and seam-burst testing are conducted with a partner lab; until then, Protection Scores cite certification inputs and say so.

FAQ

How are MotoGearRater scores calculated?

Each of the eight scores is a weighted sum of published sub-criteria, each normalized to a 0–100 value against a fixed anchor scale, then rounded. The full rubric for every score is published on this page.

Can the scores be reproduced independently?

Yes. Every score links to its inputs — specs, certifications, or test logs — and the weights are fixed and public, so the same inputs always yield the same score.

Why do some products say "Not Yet Rated"?

Because we only publish a score when we have verified inputs for at least 80% of its sub-criteria. We would rather show nothing than guess.

Do better-known or American-made brands get higher scores automatically?

No. Heritage and USA-Made are separate scores with their own rubrics. They never inflate Protection, Durability, or Value, which are judged purely on measured inputs.

Do the weights ever change?

Only with a new version number. When a rubric is revised, we recompute affected scores and note it in the changelog.

SCHEMA

Internal links: Testing Methodology hub · What Is Horsehide? · What Is CE Armor? · What Is Full-Grain Leather? · Best Horsehide Motorcycle Jackets · About MotoGearRater

External (natural): legendaryusa.com